🎁 Loyalty & Rewards

Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion

Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion: Smile.io is the most popular loyalty app with a great free plan and fast setup. LoyaltyLion offers more flexibility for enterprise programs at a higher price point.

⭐ Smile.io: 4.8/5 (6,528 reviews)
⭐ LoyaltyLion: 4.5/5 (601 reviews)
Pick Smile.io when:

You want quick setup, a strong free tier, and simple points + referrals program

"DTC brands wanting simple, reliable loyalty with a strong free tier"
Pick LoyaltyLion when:

You need custom events, complex tier rules, or a B2B/B2C hybrid loyalty program

"Brands with complex loyalty needs: custom events, multi-tier, B2B hybrid programs"

Pricing Comparison

Smile.io Free plan
Per monthly orders
Free
Points only
Free
Up to 200 orders/mo
Starter
Points + referrals
$49
/mo, up to 500 orders
Growth
+ VIP tiers, nudges
$199
/mo, up to 2,500 orders
Plus
Unlimited + custom branding
$999
/mo
LoyaltyLion Free plan
Per monthly orders
Free
Core features, LoyaltyLion branding
Free
Up to 800 orders/mo
Classic
White-label, advanced rules
$199
/mo, up to 2,000 orders
Advanced
+ Custom events, deep integrations
$399
/mo, up to 4,000 orders
Plus
Enterprise + dedicated CSM
Custom
Custom

Feature Comparison

Feature Smile.io LoyaltyLion
Points program ✓ ✓
Referral program Starter+ ✓
VIP tiers Growth+ ✓
Custom rewards Growth+ Advanced
Nudge widgets Growth+ ✓
Analytics Standard Advanced
API access ✓ ✓
POS integration ✓ ✓
White-label Plus Classic+
Free plan ✓ ✓

Pros & Cons

Smile.io

✓ Market leader — most widely used Shopify loyalty app
✓ Simple setup — live in under 1 hour
✓ Great free plan for small stores
✓ Points + referrals + VIP tiers in one
✓ Excellent documentation and community
✗ Price jumps sharply: $49 → $199 at 500 orders
✗ Limited customization on lower plans
✗ Not ideal for B2B or complex loyalty structures

LoyaltyLion

✓ Most flexible loyalty rules engine in the market
✓ Custom events (loyalty for any action)
✓ Better for complex B2B/B2C hybrid programs
✓ Generous free tier (800 orders/mo)
✗ Higher entry price ($199 vs $49 Smile.io at same tier)
✗ Steeper learning curve
✗ Smaller community than Smile.io

Who Should Use Each?

Smile.io
Best for

DTC brands wanting simple, reliable loyalty with a strong free tier

Not for

Enterprise brands with complex loyalty logic — LoyaltyLion handles custom structures better

LoyaltyLion
Best for

Brands with complex loyalty needs: custom events, multi-tier, B2B hybrid programs

Not for

Simple DTC stores — Smile.io is easier to set up and cheaper at lower volumes

Our Verdict

Smile.io for simplicity and ease of setup; LoyaltyLion for complex enterprise programs.

Choose Smile.io if:

You want quick setup, a strong free tier, and simple points + referrals program

Choose LoyaltyLion if:

You need custom events, complex tier rules, or a B2B/B2C hybrid loyalty program

View Smile.io on Shopify App Store → View LoyaltyLion on Shopify App Store →

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for Shopify: Smile.io or LoyaltyLion?

Smile.io for simplicity and ease of setup; LoyaltyLion for complex enterprise programs. Choose Smile.io when: You want quick setup, a strong free tier, and simple points + referrals program. Choose LoyaltyLion when: You need custom events, complex tier rules, or a B2B/B2C hybrid loyalty program.

Is Smile.io free?

Yes, Smile.io has a free plan: Up to 200 monthly orders, basic points.

Is LoyaltyLion free?

Yes, LoyaltyLion has a free plan: Up to 800 monthly orders.

How much does Smile.io cost?

Smile.io paid plans start at $49/mo (Per monthly orders).

How much does LoyaltyLion cost?

LoyaltyLion paid plans start at $199/mo (Per monthly orders).

What is the main difference between Smile.io and LoyaltyLion?

Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion: Smile.io is the most popular loyalty app with a great free plan and fast setup. LoyaltyLion offers more flexibility for enterprise programs at a higher price point.

Get weekly Shopify app insights

One tip per week on apps, margins, and growing your Shopify store. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Explore Further

Alternatives
Best Smile.io Alternatives →
Alternatives
Best LoyaltyLion Alternatives →
Pricing
Smile.io Pricing Plans →
Pricing
LoyaltyLion Pricing Plans →